Saying 43: The Tree and Its Fruit
Asked who he is to speak this way, Jesus replies that they do not recognise him from what he says: they have become like those who love the tree and hate its fruit, or love the fruit and hate the tree.
Commentary
The saying assumes a split audience and a hardening line. Its blunt reference to “the Jews” is one of several places where Thomas reflects a community defining itself against its parent tradition.
Parallels
Matthew 12:33; Luke 6:43–44; John 8:25
Sayings on the same themes
- Saying 100 Saying 100: Give Caesar What Is Caesar’s Shown a gold coin and told that Caesar's people demand taxes, he answers: give Caesar what belongs to Caesar, give God what…
- Saying 105 Saying 105: Whoever Knows the Father and the Mother Whoever knows the father and the mother will be called the child of a prostitute.
- Saying 52 Saying 52: Twenty-Four Prophets The disciples say twenty-four prophets spoke in Israel and all of them spoke about him; he replies that they have ignored the…
- Saying 39 Saying 39: The Keys of Knowledge The Pharisees and scholars have taken the keys of knowledge and hidden them; they did not go in themselves and did not…
- Saying 114 Saying 114: Simon Peter and Mary Simon Peter says Mary should leave, because women are not worthy of life. Jesus answers that he will guide her so that…
- Saying 65 Saying 65: The Wicked Tenants A man leased his vineyard to farmers. He sent a servant for the produce and they beat him; he sent another and…